Irish coastal communities ‘will be annihilated’ in Brexit fishing stand-off
Irish coastal communities ‘will be annihilated’ in Brexit fishing stand-off© Niall Carson Fishing boats return their catch to Howth Harbour in Co Dublin (Niall Carson/PA)
Irish coastal communities will be “annihilated” if Britain’s post-Brexit fishing demands are granted, an Oireachtas committee has been told.
Fishing rights has been one of the key sticking points which has threatened to overthrow Brexit negotiations.
The British Government has said that, as the UK is now an independent coastal state, it should be able to prioritise its own fleets.
Ireland’s fishing industry said it is concerned about Boris Johnson’s demands for UK’s fishing rights within Britain’s waters.© Provided by PA Media Patrick Murphy
Patrick Murphy, chief executive of the Irish South and West Fish Producers Organisation (IS&WFPO), said that, if EU fishing fleets are allowed access to only 12% of the fish in the UK, it would have grave consequences for Irish coastal communities.
“Those figures are frightening, they are staggering,” Mr Murphy told the Agriculture committee.
“There’s no industry that would be able to sustain that on top of the boats that would be displaced looking for fish.
“(We) are noticing boats that we haven’t been seen in Irish waters before – new boats coming in to try and catch fish and that’s an added competition.© Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile via Getty Images Donegal , Ireland – 8 August 2020;
A view of action during the Donegal Junior League Glencar Inn Division One match between Arranmore United and Milford United Reserves at Rannagh Park in Arranmore, Donegal. The island of Arranmore is off the west coast of County Donegal, with a population of 469. (Photo By Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile via Getty Images)
“These are jobs in the local community that are not going to be replaced with anything else.
“It would be an annihilation of our coastal communities, towns and villages and that is not something that may happen, it has already happened.
“That could be the final death knell.
“We have around 1,000 fishermen fishing the boats in the Cork region, and we are told that each one of those jobs lost will cost five more ashore.
“The figures are startling.”© BEN STANSALL/AFP via Getty Images
A man takes a selfie photo atop the Durdle Door rock, as a Cruise ship is seen in the sea beyond, near West Lulworth on the south coast of England on May 24, 2020. – Travellers arriving in Britain will face 14 days in quarantine from next month to prevent a second coronavirus outbreak, the government announced on Friday, warning that anyone breaking the rules faced a fine or prosecution. The new rules will apply to all international arrivals except Ireland from June 8 and come after weeks of calls for tougher restrictions to curb the spread of COVID-19. (Photo by Ben STANSALL / AFP) (Photo by BEN STANSALL/AFP via Getty Images)
He also raised concerns about an increase in EU fishing fleets accessing Irish waters.
Mr Murphy said that biologically sensitive areas where fish are spawned should be protected.
“You are going to see a massive amount of vessels coming in to an area, regardless of the quota share they have, and we are fearful of the impact it could have on biologically sensitive areas,” Mr Murphy warned.
“The area that definitely needs protecting is the goose that lays the golden egg and that’s our fishing grounds.
“If we damage biologically sensitive areas where fish come to spawn, those fish travel and that’s why we are so adamant with the UK that you can’t just grab those fish because they are in your waters when you want to catch them.© Getty Keem beach in County Mayo. Blue Flag beach.
“They come to our waters to spawn and if you don’t have the spawning they won’t be in your waters.
“It’s all about linking the trade and if we break that linkage we are doomed.”
Ireland’s fishing industry do not know whether it will have access to UK waters, or how much fish the UK will be given in Irish waters.
“The complication is we don’t know how much fish we will have to give up, we don’t know what will be left in the pot and we certainly don’t know how many vessels are coming in,” Mr Murphy added.
Most fish caught by UK fishermen are sold in Europe and Britain needs to maintain access to EU markets.
The EU and the UK may have to compromise on how much access they want and what share of the quota they are allowed.© Liam McBurney/PA Images via Getty Images
Garda Tom McBride with Presiding Officer for Gola Island Nancy Sharkey, carry an election ballot box pass the statue of the Virgin Mary on the island’s harbour, off the coast of Donegal, Ireland, to be returned to the mainland after Islanders had the opportunity to cast their vote a day ahead of the rest of the country in the Irish election. (Photo by Liam McBurney/PA Images via Getty Images)
Sean O’Donoghue, chief executive of Killybegs Fishermen’s Organisation, said a temporary agreement between both sides would have the same consequences as a no-deal.
“If we end up in that scenario we will have the demise of the Irish seafood sector, which is in a very healthy state at the moment,” Mr O’Donoghue warned.
“These are coastal communities that are dependant on fisheries and, if we lose access, we could lose 5,000 to 6,000 jobs over a period of one to two years of the 16,100 involved in the industry.
“The value of the seafood industry would be decreased from 1.22 billion euro to between 600 and 700 million.
“That would be the demise of the Irish seafood industry.”
A fisherman from Dublin said Ireland should return to the table in Brussels and ask for a bigger fishing quota.© CATHAL NOONAN/AFP via Getty Images
The abandoned 77-metre (250-feet) cargo ship MV Alta is pictured stuck on rocks near the village of Ballycotton south-east of Cork in Southern Ireland on February 18, 2020. – A “ghost ship” drifting without a crew for more than a year washed ashore on Ireland’s south coast in high seas caused by Storm Dennis, the Republic’s coast guard said. (Photo by Cathal Noonan / AFP) (Photo by CATHAL NOONAN/AFP via Getty Images)
Mark McLoughlin, who has worked in the industry all his life and owns Nicky’s Plaice in Howth, said: “Irish fishermen are going to lose 80% of fishing catches and yet we have the second largest fishing waters in Europe, and when Britain leaves the EU, it means Ireland will have the largest fishing waters. Yet, we are being starved of fish.
“Irishmen can’t fish in Irish waters yet all over Europe the French, the Germans, the Spanish, they’re all fishing in Irish water getting fish that the Irish are not allowed.
“The biggest problem we have is quota, quota, quota.
“If England has a hard Brexit, it’s going to be a problem. If they get a deal there’s no reason why Ireland shouldn’t go back to the table and look for a little more than 4% out of the quota for Irish fish in Irish waters.
“The Irish government should go to Europe and get more out of our fishing waters. We’ve got an industry worth 6 million (euro) of which we only get 4%. It’s crazy.