Ex-inmate who claimed he slipped on butter packet in Midlands Prison loses €60,000 compensation claim
28th October 2021
A former inmate at Midlands Prison, Portlaoise, who fell on a stairwell in the prison seven years ago, lost a €60,000 personal injuries claim in the Circuit Civil Court today against the Minister for Justice.
Graham Hynes, of Oakland Grove, Kildare Town, Co Kildare, told Judge Cormac Quinn he slipped on a small butter packet as he was climbing the stairwell in B Wing of the prison.
He said he had fallen heavily on his right knee, injuring his leg and twisting his back. Initially he had not wanted to make a complaint against the Governor but later did so.
Hynes told barrister Damian Sheridan – who appeared for the minister with Deirdre O’Halloran of Corrigan and Corrigan Solicitors – that he had broken his leg in an earlier accident outside of the prison, but this injury had cleared up and he was symptom-free prior to the stairwell fall in August 2014.
He said particles of food would often fall off trays and butter packets were thrown around by some inmates.
He had been looking ahead at the time and had not seen the butter packet on the second-last step at the top of the stairwell.
Forensic engineer Paul Romeril told the court food was regularly carried up the stairwell in question by inmates returning with food trays to their cells.
He said there had been photographic evidence of the stairwell itself but he did not think it would be useful to the court in determining the issue.
Mr Romeril said cleaning in the wing was carried out while inmates were locked up between 10am and noon, when they would be released to have their food.
Judge Quinn, in dismissing Hynes’s case, said he had received methadone earlier that day for treatment of a drug dependency problem and he may have been intoxicated at the time of the incident.
The judge said he would also have dismissed the case on the basis Hynes had not been holding on to the stairwell railings, knew the area well and should have been looking where he was going at the time.
He directed that he pay the minister’s legal costs in the case.