Judge, former Motor Bike Cop, Nolan, showed Mercy Today; Some may Say, Selective Justice? Russell lost his Job and the Rest, Greed?

Posted by

Former St Vincent’s hospital staff member avoids jail after spending €22k on company credit card- 1h ag

TODAY COURTS, MONDAY 11 JULY 2022

A FORMER STAFF member at St Vincent’s University Hospital who fraudulently used a company credit card to make purchases of over €22,000 has avoided a jail term.

Gerard Russell (55) of New Park Road, Blackrock, pleaded guilty to six counts of theft and deception on dates between August 2014 and June 2015

An audit was performed after transactions of a “domestic and personal nature” raised a red flag. A large number of items were delivered to the hospital and some recovered from his home.

Russell has no previous convictions. There was no victim impact statement before the court.

The total amount involved was €22,353 and Russell had this available to the court.

Judge Martin Nolan said Russell had stolen from his employer and while the amount involved was quite low compared to other cases, the breach of trust was serious.

He took into account Russell’s co-operation, guilty pleas and absence of a criminal record. He said Russell was unlikely to reoffend.

He noted the letters from people who know him portraying him in a very good light. He said he also had the benefit of a psychological report.

Judge Nolan said he did not think a prison term would be just and imposed a three-year suspended sentence. He ordered the amount of €22,353 be transferred to St Vincent’s within one week.

Garda Aidan Coffey told Diarmuid Collins BL, prosecuting, that Russell had worked as a purchasing and procurement manager at St Vincent’s Hospital. He said after a number of receipts were found in a box in his office, an audit was performed and certain transactions were identified.

He said Russell had used a credit card that was supposed to be used to buy items needed for the hospital. Staff confirmed they had received deliveries in his name to the hospital.

The transactions were for items that were domestic and personal in nature so raised a red flag.

As well as a large number of items delivered to the hospital, 19 items were found at his home.

Collins agreed with Giollaiosa Ó Lideadha SC, defending, that Russell’s wife had written a letter in which she outlined that once he had conquered alcoholism in 2013, he replaced that addiction with another in relation to spending money on small purchases.

His wife wrote that Russell was a kind and generous man who was an addict. She outlined voluntary work he has carried out for others in crisis. Other family members also wrote letters.

Mr Russell wrote a letter of apology taking responsibility for his actions and expressing remorse.

Ó Lideadha said his client had suffered depression and mental health issues following the death of his mother and managed to conquer his alcoholism in 2013. He has a bipolar diagnosis, is on medication and has undergone counselling.

He submitted there were exceptional circumstances in this case and said the offending fits with a pattern of mental health issues rather than a greed issue. He said Russell had a history which goes to explain his addiction and “messed-up thought processes.”

He said it was a “complicated mixed bag” involving a combination of depression and mania. He said Russell continues to work with the difficult combination of psychological and psychiatric circumstances with the support of his family and was unlikely to reoffend.

He said Russell has lost his job and suffered public humiliation.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s