One Punch, Sadly can Kill, another Human Being, Tragedy here?

Posted by

‘GRIEF STRICKEN’ 

Former Derry GAA star and bar owner charged with manslaughter over alleged one-punch killing

  • 19:33, 3 Nov 2022
  • Updated: 19:33, 3 Nov 2022

A BAR owner and ex-GAA team captain has been charged with manslaughter over an alleged one-punch killing.

Grieving relatives of Aaron Law, 34, looked on as 41-year-old Fergal Gerard Doherty appeared in court via videolink.

Fergal Gerard Doherty appeared in court via videolink
Fergal Gerard Doherty appeared in court via videolinkCredit: Sportsfile – Subscription
Joe Brolly was defence counsel
Joe Brolly was defence counselCredit: Sportsfile – Subscription

Dad-of-two Law was found unconscious outside a Co Antrim bar at about 1.10am on Sunday.

He had suffered a head injury and was taken to hospital but later died.

Ballymena magistrates court heard today how Mr Law had been at a stag party at Pat’s Bar, Portglenone, Co Antrim, when a doorman “escorted” him out.

Outside, the victim had a “verbal altercation” with the doorman and according to defence counsel Joe Brolly, Mr Law “swung a punch” at Doherty when he tried to intervene but the retired Gaelic footballer retaliated, punching the victim once.

DS Brannigan agreed with the barrister’s suggestions that according to the defendant, two witness statements and pathology evidence, Doherty’s punch caused Mr Law to fall and strike his head on the road way.

The detective added however that with Mr Law lying unconscious in the middle of the road, the doorman and Doherty “left him and returned to the bar.”

The court heard he was left lying for up to 15 minutes and that at one stage, a car had to brake and drive around him before parking further down the street.

After ten to 15 minutes from the initial incident, the doorman and Doherty went back outside and pulled Mr Law from the roadway but there was still no medical assistance sought and instead, they “propped him up against the wall of the bar.”

It was only when a sober member of the public noticed that Mr Law needed medical assistance that an ambulance was called and the paramedics in turn contacted the police. He later died in hospital.

Police investigating the tragic death spoke to the doorman and to Doherty who both initially claimed they did not know how Mr Law came to be hurt but the court also heard that during a phone conversation with the victim’s brother in law, the “extremely distressed” defendant admitted he had thrown a punch and that he intended to hand himself in to police.

DS Brannigan outlined how Doherty gave a “full account” of his version of events, claiming that he had acted in self defence when he punched Mr Law once in the face.

“His account has been corroborated by other individuals,” said the detective, adding that with around 30 people in the bar, investigators have spoken to around half of them but are still conducting a live investigation.

He told the court police were objecting to bail due to fears that Doherty could interfere with the ongoing investigation or could commit further offences, even though he has a clear record.

‘TERRIBLE TRAGEDY’

Under cross examination from Mr Brolly, the DS agreed that the witness accounts taken to date “entirely corroborates” Doherty’s account with “nothing to contradict his account” that he acted in self defence.

Turning to his submissions, Mr Brolly conceded that although “it’s really a terrible, terrible tragedy” for the Law family, he argued that Doherty should not have been charged in the first place given he was acting in self defence and also that there was an “overwhelming case” for the alleged killer to be grated bail.

“Mr Doherty is a very well known young man who played Gaelic football for Bellaghy, Derry and Ulster with distinction,” said Mr Brolly adding that he has a “clear record and no trouble with the police” and the bar has been shut since the incident.

“In the circumstances of this case, it’s as obvious a case of self defence as I have come across in 30 years of practice as a criminal defence barrister,” Mr Brolly submitted, describing Doherty as “devastated and grief stricken” at Mr Law’s tragic death.

Despite his exhortations however, District Judge Nigel Broderick refused to free Doherty

Commenting that more than a dozen witnesses still needed to be spoken to in the live investigation which centred around a “small rural community,” the judge said he was concerned about the risk of the witnesses and the investigation being interfered with or instructed.

Remanding Doherty into custody, he adjourned the case to 1 December.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s